Shorten’s stereotyping of homosexuality is offensive and demeaning

  • Written by Josh Manuatu

In the latest example of gross stereotyping and intolerance opposition leader Bill Shorten’s comments that the marriage plebiscite could cause young gay people to commit suicide are to be condemned. Apart from being deeply demeaning, this type of intervention simply promulgates an outdated and false stereotype of homosexuality in society.


Worse still, his statement is not based in fact or evidence – aside from statements from ideologues there is no Australian data to suggest that LGBTI people take their lives at much higher rates. Indeed, a 2014 study in Queensland found that only 0.5 per cent of the almost 6,000 cases examined were members of the LGBTI community.


Instead of expressing confidence in the Australian people to have a respectful discussion on marriage, Mr Shorten has chosen to spit out sensationalised prerehearsed lines designed to make the TV and print news in an attempt to shame Australians into backing his view.

While I absolutely accept, and can attest, that it is not always easy growing up as someone who is gay – and to compound matters, to be a gay conservative – but the vast bulk of LGBTI people that I know are smart, articulate and strong individuals.


Mr Shorten’s continued push of the stereotype that all homosexuals are sad, impulsive and not in control of their emotions to the extent that a TV advertisement may force them to commit suicide is not only offensive and deeply demeaning but, I am sure, would be doing more harm than good for any young person coming to grips with their sexuality – and for nothing more than making a political point.


If Mr Shorten were genuine about wanting to better support young people who are suffering depression – and let’s be clear here, youth depression and suicide is a BIG problem across the whole community not just amongst LGBTI people – he would be talking up the positive contribution that people from all walks of life can make in Australia. That we are an aspirational nation where it doesn’t matter your gender, race or sexuality if you set your mind to it you can achieve whatever you like.


Instead his belittling stereotypes only make people feel more isolated and alone.


If Mr Shorten were so sure of his position on marriage he would be welcoming a vote of the people with an open embrace not clutching at every excuse to oppose it – from labelling all opponents of change as homophobic to now inferring that supporters of marriage will have blood on their hands.


This kind of behaviour is not only unbecoming it just again demonstrates why Bill Shorten is unfit to be prime minister.

Josh Manuatu is the Development Director of the Young Liberal Movement of Australia and a staffer to Liberal Senator Eric Abetz

More Articles ...

  1. Review of Foreign Donations and GetUp welcome
  2. Barnaby Joyce - Help us to win the war on pests & weeds
  3. Critical IR reform bills presented to parliament
  4. Sam Dastyari has been involved in funny money deals
  5. Primary Industries Levies and Charges Collection Amendment Bill
  6. Farm Co-operatives and Collaboration Pilot Program
  7. Next steps on Work PaTHway for Young Australians
  8. Prime Minister - Interview with Alan Jones
  9. Andrew Wilkie confirms his neutral status for new Parliament
  10. Post election conference by Malcolm Turnbull and Barnaby Joyce
  11. Tactical Changes in Russia’s Foreign Policy and Iran's Caution
  12. City Deal for Western Sydney
  13. Growing the Indigenous Business Sector
  14. Trade and investment to drive jobs and growth
  15. Malcolm Turnbull announces Townsville Eastern Access Rail Corridor
  16. ACL calls on Labor to rule out money for teaching kids their gender is fluid
  17. Prime Minister Transcript Interview on Territory FM Darwin
  18. Labor to slug 18,000 Tasmanian renters by $500 each year
  19. Australia election political meeting season begins for ALA candidate Bernard Gaynor
  20. Empowering YOUth Initiative
  21. New Federal Young Liberal Executive
  22. ABC’s crisis of conscience welcome after years of denial
  23. Army's halal ration packs are 'dangerous appeasement'
  24. Malcolm Turnbull Press Conference on announcement of changes to ministry
  25. Cure the problem, don’t treat the symptoms
  26. ParentsNext - helping parents with young children prepare for work
  27. Malcolm Turnbull at Jane McGrath High Tea at the Commonwealth Bank Pink Test SCG, Sydney
  28. Stronger protections for VET students commence
  29. Abetz - New ABC boss must stop lefty love-in
  30. Malcolm Turnbull address to Japan Chamber of Commerce and Industry Tokyo Japan
  31. Senator Abetz - Q&A Review only seeks to embed bias
  32. Stronger together: Effective service coordination to overcome disadvantage
  33. Michaelia Cash - Labour force figures released reveal more Australians are now in work
  34. Labor’s epiphany on union governance too little to late
  35. Bolt Report interview with Senator Brandis
  36. Australia’s new state-of-the-art icebreaker unveiled
  37. Turnbull unveils cabinet line-up: experts respond
  38. Labor and the ACTU – No Policy, No Plan and No Idea on Youth Unemployment
  39. Labor’s NSW mega-electorate proposal shows contempt for regions
  40. Changes in Saudi Arabia Aimed at Blocking Iran's Regional Clout
  41. Tax system review applauded by REINSW
  42. Prime Minister's Press Release New South Wales election result
  43. Baird's back in NSW: experts react to the Coalition win
  44. Tony Abbott address to Victorian Liberal Party State Council

George Neophytou supports roads funding and more

Independent candidate for Gippsland East George Neophytou has pledged to support completion of duplication of the Princes Highway between Traralgon and Sale and to upgrading of the Sale alternative ...

Scott Morrison interview with Alan Jones

Belt and Road Initiative; Law and order in Victoria; Queensland infrastructure; Power prices; Paris Agreement; Immigration; Negative gearing.   ALAN JONES: Prime Minister, good morning.   PRIME ...

George Neophytou a real force to stop the Fingerboards Mine

George Neophytou a solicitor contesting the election as an Independent Candidate has been an activist against the Fingerboards Mineral Sands Mine for over two years. His track record shows ability a...

Scott Morrison Q&A Asia Briefing

Foreign affairs; foreign investment; a stronger economy and lower taxes; energy; climate policy;   QUESTION: Prime Minister, it’s such a pleasure to have you here at Bloomberg and in conversation w...

George Neophytou supports justice for CFA Volunteers

Independent candidate for Gippsland East, George Neophytou, has joined the Coalition commitment to justice for Country Fire Authority (CFA) volunteers and would support the Coalition’s Presumptive L...

Canavan welcomes first shipment for Ichthys

Resources Minister Matthew Canavan has welcomed the first shipment overnight of liquefied natural gas (LNG) from the INPEX-operated Ichthys LNG Project’s onshore LNG processing facilities in Darwin...

Business News


Hussh . . . The Secret is Out Your exclusive invitation to 9 massive warehouse sales this week The secret to huge savings is shopping directly from the warehouses of Australia’s biggest wholesa...

Web Wisdom - Simple Ways to Increase Sales as an e-Commerce Website

The online marketplace is a virtual paradise for consumers who love a bargain. Today’s e-commerce has become so evolved that consumers not only have purchasing power, but they also can influence maj...

Digital marketing agencies are fudging the numbers and distorting the outcomes for their clients

Many digital marketing agencies manipulate reports to make themselves look good, offering vanity stats that really provide no benefit to their clients. One of the most common mistakes companies make...


Pet-Friendly Summer Destinations in NZ

No one wants to leave their pet at home and why should you have to? When it comes to traveling around in a campervan hire New Zealand, you may not want to live your precious animal back home. You shou...


DON’T GET SLUGGED WITH THE SIX-HUNDRED-DOLLAR CHRISTMAS TAX Revealed: traditional car rental companies charging 3.3 times more to rent a vehicle over Christmas A comparison of rental costs per day...

Looking for a Romantic Destination? Here’s Why the Philippines May Be Perfect for You

Image Source: https://pixabay.com/en/couple-man-woman-girl-guy-love-2585328/Perhaps, you want a spot to celebrate your honeymoon after several months of wedding planning. Or, maybe you are just loo...