Daily Bulletin

Is a story about heterosexual coupling the queerest film of the past year?

  • Written by The Conversation Contributor
image

Mainstream screen stories like Brokeback Mountain, The Kids Are All Right, Carol, Transparent and Looking have brought GLBTI lives into the multiplex and loungeroom. Sexually dissident characters seem no longer trapped in what film historian Vito Russo in 1981 memorably called the celluloid closet.

But what stories are these films telling? What are they celebrating or critiquing, and is representing non-straight or non-binary characters the only point that matters?

When the British Film Institute released a list of the 30 Best LGBT Films of All Time earlier this year, it was dominated by love plots. So too, queer film festivals are often crowded with narratives about romance, thwarted or otherwise.

From one point of view, though, the flowering of these seemingly dissident love stories represents a conservative step. Drawing on traditions of queer theory, some critics wonder what the political consequences of centralising the love story might be. Others suggest that recent queer cinema has a disturbing tendency to create a moralising panic about sexual practices that transgress the model of monogamous coupledom.

However, queer cinema continues to play an integral role in championing queer rights. Curzon’s Best LGBTQ+ films list shines a light on the evolving social attitudes in queer films while also being mindful of current prejudices.

Queer theory took shape in the early 1990s, asking searching questions about the relationship between desire, identity and politics. Thinkers like Judith Butler argued that our identities aren’t set, but created; they’re an effect of social and power relations, rather than the ground upon which those relations unfold. Identity might be something you do, rather than who you are.

This also means identity categories are historically dynamic and malleable; they change over time – both in a broader cultural sense and in our own experiences.

The contest over “marriage equality” demonstrates the distinction between striving for recognition, and disrupting the terms under which that recognition is offered. Activists like Rodney Croome argue that gays and lesbians are excluded from full cultural citizenship because they’re denied the capacity to marry. For Croome and many others, specific sexual minorities deserve to have their love recognised.

Queer theorists like Annamarie Jagose, though, worry that these campaigns for recognition once-again normalise monogamous coupledom as the natural destination and desire for all. They suggest these campaigns tend to marginalise dissident desires. In so doing, they make life for those whose sexual and intimate lives fall outside the boundaries of the respectable couple more difficult.

I was a little surprised, then, to find myself recognising a distinctly queer sensibility in a recent film about the perils and pitfalls of heterosexual coupling - The Lobster (2015). Hailed by many critics as a dystopian love story steeped in the loneliness of modern life, to a queer reader, this film looks more like a savage critique of romantic love itself.

Directed by Yorgos Lanthimos, The Lobster imagines a near future in which single people are removed from The City, and admitted to The Hotel. Once admitted, if they don’t find a romantic partner within 45 days they will be transformed into an animal of their choosing.

David (Colin Farrell in an endearing performance as a short-sighted man with an adorable paunch) selects a lobster. He spends the next third of the film engaging in summer camp-like activities that mix match-making with ideological education. These single men and women, it would seem, must have forgotten the benefits of coupled life.

No character except David has a name, everybody else is known for a singular characteristic; The Short-Sighted Woman, The Limping Man, The Nosebleed Woman … Part of the film’s humour is produced by the sense that these individuals are being reduced to a singular characteristic, much like a menu of romantic possibilities. They simply must find their match.

After a strange narrative turn, David escapes to The Forest where a band of singles carve out a life of resistant survival. They reject the laws of The City and proclaim their capacity to exist as fully human outside the structure of the couple. In this environment, in fact, coupling is forbidden. Once a week the rebels get together for a boogie, but they only listen to electronic music, “because you have to dance alone.” It is, of course, in the forest where David meets his romantic match – a similarly short-sighted woman.

Expressed like this, The Lobster doesn’t sound tremendously funny, and yet it conforms to the usual plot of a romantic comedy. In this case, though, we are encouraged to be a little suspicious about the rules of this narrative game. What are the costs of living happily ever after, and what kind of lives do these ideals make impossible?

The Lobster is thus a profoundly discomforting film – and I suspect this is also why many film critics have struggled to write coherently about it. It is both utterly comical and completely confronting. One critic tellingly called the film “hideously funny.”

Perhaps this is no laughing matter. The narrative destination of coupledom exerts tremendous force in our imaginative and social worlds.

The Lobster takes this one step further. Characters treat friendships as stepping-stones as they move towards their romantic destination, and this means they can be shucked off with little consequence. The sovereignty of the couple completely orders their relational and political world.

Whilst our human rights might not be dependant on the achievement of romantic encouplement, the UN declaration of human rights does privilege the reproductive couple as an entitlement of political humanity. This historically contingent form of kinship is granted special status. So too, we don’t have to look very hard to realise that a whole raft of political and cultural privileges accrue around marriage and marriage-like relationships.

Indeed, as critic Guy Lodge noted in Variety, the “laws of [this] mundane dystopia…don’t look severely different from the world we live in now.” The resonances with our own world should be clear: this is simply a dystopian amplification of the cultural ideals we face every day.

Queer theorists ask thorny questions about how historically specific ideals and norms become entangled with, and perhaps even determine, our emotional lives. Romantic love, from this perspective, is a profoundly political feeling. The end of The Lobster is similarly unsettling; it is not clear whether we should be troubled or excited by romantic success and its associated costs.

It isn’t clear what alternative forms of kinship might take shape if we loosened the grip of the romantic couple on our interior and cultural lives – but queer films like The Lobster ask questions that encourage us to step into this unsteady and dangerous world.

Authors: The Conversation Contributor

Read more http://theconversation.com/is-a-story-about-heterosexual-coupling-the-queerest-film-of-the-past-year-58779

Read more

Aspiring treasurer Chris Bowen looks fit for purpose

  • Written by The Conversation Contributor

Chris Bowen’s presented at the National Press Club on Tuesday as a well-prepared alternative treasurer, who could slot into the real job very easily if July 2 brought the chance.

“Neat” is the word that came to mind about Bowen’s performance. His critique of the government was strong but not over the top; he firmly linked...

Read more

More Articles ...

  1. Why nosebands should be loosened on dressage horses at the Olympics
  2. FactCheck: does Labor have a $19.5b black hole in its funding plan?
  3. What the Reserve Bank memo really says about negative gearing
  4. Call yourself a cosmetic surgeon? New guidelines fix only half the problem
  5. A Moon Shaped Pool and the unmistakable alchemy of Radiohead
  6. Lessons from living below the extreme poverty line on $2 a day
  7. Indonesia sets new rules for ride-sharing companies
  8. Why Bill Shorten 'stars' in both sides' election ads
  9. How your garden could help stop your city flooding
  10. Super contribution cap changes could end up benefiting the rich
  11. Comment moderation during the election
  12. Media picture of urban consolidation focuses more on a good scare story than the facts
  13. The Turnbull of old
  14. From donkey votes to dog whistles, our election language has a long and political history
  15. Queensland moves to control land clearing: other states need to follow
  16. Explainer: why we can't fix the structural deficit without tax and spending reform
  17. Memo to Michelle Guthrie: as local newspapers die, might the ABC help out?
  18. When the scrotum is empty: undescended testes don't only affect kids
  19. Blockchain is useful for a lot more than just Bitcoin
  20. Go target the Liberals, Albanese tells the Greens on his tail
  21. Rushed reform benefits no one in the end
  22. The Philippines: former sick man of Asia suffers relapse
  23. Five ways Reg Grundy changed Australian TV (for better or worse)
  24. Fraudulent loans point to due diligence problems at Australia's major banks
  25. #ausvotes Revisited: Social Media in the 2013 Australian Federal Election
  26. Health Check: how to get off the couch and into exercise
  27. The Logies: a yearly advertisement for Australian TV
  28. Tax reform might happen if we could see everyone's tax return
  29. Liberal divisions can be a source of strength, not weakness, in the election campaign
  30. Build in good services from day one for healthier communities: lessons from Selandra Rise
  31. Black Velvet: redefining and celebrating Indigenous Australian women in art
  32. Coalition gains slightly in post-budget polls
  33. We all live downstream – it's time to restore our freshwater ecosystems
  34. Towards a collaborative city: the case for a Melbourne Metropolitan Commission
  35. The NSW government is choosing to undermine native vegetation and biodiversity
  36. Fans deserve fair play in major sports, not cheating and corruption
  37. The off-topic Conversation #92
  38. Student loan caps must be part of total redesign of vocational funding system
  39. Lessons from history in how to run a good election campaign – or how to avoid a really bad one
  40. Rapid transition to clean energy will take massive social change
  41. What if tax reform was a fundamental human right?
  42. Memo to Michelle Guthrie: expert ideas for the new ABC era
  43. Why do some old men have big red noses? No, it's not alcohol
  44. Integrity in sport needs to grow from the grassroots level
  45. Will the internships program help young people get jobs?
  46. Coalition and Labor close in Ipsos and Newspoll as election race starts
  47. In the Nakamoto fiasco, Reddit proves a more reliable source of crowdsourced analysis
  48. The President of Humility
  49. Negotiating the media minefields in a world where radio is no longer king
  50. Election explainer: what does it mean that we're having a double-dissolution election?

Business News

How Freight Forwarding Simplifies Global Trade Operations

Global trade operations are becoming increasingly complex due to international regulations, customs procedures, and the sheer scale of global logistics. For businesses looking to expand internation...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

How Car Accident Lawyers Protect Your Rights?

In the aftermath of a car accident, the steps you take can significantly impact your financial and legal future. This is where car accident lawyers step into the frame, equipped with expertise to sa...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin

Solutions Bridging Agriculture and Bulk Liquid Transport

The agricultural industry is heavily reliant on the efficient transport and storage of various liquids, from water and fertilisers to chemicals and pesticides. With farms often situated in rural or ...

Daily Bulletin - avatar Daily Bulletin