Daily Bulletin


The Conversation

  • Written by Kumuda Simpson, Lecturer in International Relations, La Trobe University
The Conversation

Justice Anthony Kennedy’s retirement from the US Supreme Court has given President Donald Trump the opportunity to nominate a second justice in the span of 18 months, and in doing so, shape the decisions of the court for decades to come.

The court is the highest in the country and serves as one of the three fundamental pillars in the US political system, alongside the executive and legislative branches. This separation of powers, enshrined in the US Constitution, has long been regarded as one of the strengths of the US political system. But as American politics has turned increasingly partisan in recent years, the Supreme Court has become an unfortunate flashpoint of the ideological battles between left and right.

With nine sitting justices, the court has often been split 5-4, at times favouring an strict, literal approach to constitutional interpretation, at others swinging back towards a pragmatist approach.

Read more: Is the Supreme Court's legitimacy undermined in a polarized age?

As some of the most contentious political, economic and social debates in the US, such as gun control, gay marriage and abortion, are fought within the highest legal institution in the country, the ideological balance of power on the court matters greatly. The justice holding the swing vote, who has been Kennedy in recent years, carries enormous power to shape the laws of the country for generations.

Trump’s nominee, Brett Kavanaugh, has an impeccable legal background, and yet has come in for fierce criticism from both Republicans and Democrats.

Opposition on both sides of the aisle

For Democrats, Kavanaugh is regarded as too partisan, having worked on some of the most controversial legal cases in recent US politics. This includes his role as part of independent counsel Kenneth Starr’s investigations into former President Bill Clinton, which culminated in the Starr report to Congress arguing that Clinton should be impeached for lying about the nature of his relationship with Monica Lewinsky.

Kavanaugh was also part of George W. Bush’s legal team in the Supreme Court case over the disputed presidential election result between Bush and Al Gore in Florida in 2000. The decision in that case resulted in Bush winning the presidency, and Kavanaugh went on to work for him in the White House.

For Republican critics, however, Kavanaugh’s record on abortion and health care is viewed as not being conservative enough.

Abortion is the issue that will garner the most attention in the upcoming confirmation battle in Congress and mobilise both the left and the right. The right to get an abortion is protected for women under the 1973 Supreme Court decision in Roe v. Wade, which ruled that:

For the stage prior to approximately the end of the first trimester, the abortion decision and its effectuation must be left to the medical judgement of the pregnant woman’s attending physician.

Yet this right has been steadily undermined and eroded over the past 45 years as conservatives opposed to Roe v. Wade have used a variety of legal tools to limit women’s access to abortion providers.

Thin record on abortion

Kavanaugh’s record on abortion in both public statements and legal decisions appears careful, emphasising legal precedent over calls to change the law. This has drawn intense criticism from some conservatives.

When asked about abortion in his 2006 confirmation hearings to be appointed to the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, Kavanaugh stated, “I would follow Roe v. Wade faithfully and fully … It’s been reaffirmed many times”.

For some Republicans, his judicial restraint is seen as being too similar to Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts, who has come under criticism for not being a reliably conservative vote.

Conservatives see this Supreme Court pick by Trump as an opportunity to radically reshape the ideological outlook of the court for generations, a chance they fear would be wasted on someone regarded as too centrist on key issues.

For the time being, it appears Democrats are gearing up for a confirmation fight, perhaps intending to delay any decision on Kennedy’s successor until after the mid-term elections in November, when they have a chance to wrest back some control over Congress and the future direction of the court.

Read more: Supreme Court polarization is not inevitable — just look at Europe

Senate Democratic Leader Charles Schumer has already signalled his intention to fight Kavanaugh’s nomination, saying: “I will oppose Judge Kavanaugh’s nomination with everything I have, and I hope a bipartisan majority will do the same. The stakes are simply too high for anything less.”

Authors: Kumuda Simpson, Lecturer in International Relations, La Trobe University

Read more http://theconversation.com/who-is-us-supreme-court-nominee-brett-kavanaugh-and-where-does-he-stand-on-abortion-99670

Writers Wanted

The big barriers to global vaccination: patent rights, national self-interest and the wealth gap

arrow_forward

After riots, Donald Trump leaves office with under 40% approval

arrow_forward

Five ways Australians can save the planet without lifting a finger (well, almost!)

arrow_forward

The Conversation
INTERWEBS DIGITAL AGENCY

Politics

Ray Hadley's interview with Scott Morrison

RAY HADLEY: Prime Minister, good morning.    PRIME MINISTER: G’day Ray.   HADLEY: I was just referring to this story from the Courier Mail, which you’ve probably caught up with today about t...

Ray Hadley & Scott Morrison - avatar Ray Hadley & Scott Morrison

Prime Minister's Remarks to Joint Party Room

PRIME MINISTER: Well, it is great to be back in the party room, the joint party room. It’s great to have everybody back here. It’s great to officially welcome Garth who joins us. Welcome, Garth...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Prime Minister Interview with Ben Fordham, 2GB

BEN FORDHAM: Scott Morrison, good morning to you.    PRIME MINISTER: Good morning, Ben. How are you?    FORDHAM: Good. How many days have you got to go?   PRIME MINISTER: I've got another we...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

7 foolproof tips for bidding successfully at a property auction

Auctions can be beneficial for prospective buyers, as they are transparent and fair. If you reach the limit you are willing to pay, you can simply walk away. Another benefit of an auction is tha...

Dominique Grubisa - avatar Dominique Grubisa

Getting Ready to Code? These Popular and Easy Programming Languages Can Get You Started

According to HOLP (History Encyclopedia of Programing Languages), there are more than 8,000 programming languages, some dating as far back as the 18th century. Although there might be as many pr...

News Co - avatar News Co

Avoid These Mistakes When Changing up Your Executive Career

Switching up industries is a valid move at any stage in your career, even if you’re an executive. Doing so at this stage can be a lot more intimidating, however, and it can be quite difficult know...

News Co - avatar News Co



News Co Media Group

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion