Daily Bulletin


The Conversation

  • Written by The Conversation Contributor
image

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has said the Australian people will have their say on same-sex marriage in a plebiscite after the next election. But Coalition senator Eric Abetz claims he and other Liberal MPs do not have to respect the plebiscite’s result, and may not vote to legalise same-sex marriage even if the Australian people vote “yes”.

Fellow Liberal senator Cory Bernardi declared he would never vote to legalise same-sex marriage – as has Nationals senator Bridget McKenzie.

Turnbull told parliament last year that:

… the consequence of a “yes” vote in the plebiscite will be that same-sex marriage will be legal in Australia.

A plebiscite does not bind MPs in any future vote on a piece of legislation. Consequently, it is possible that an MP who does not like the plebiscite’s result would try to find some justification for ignoring it if legislation on this issue were to come before parliament.

Ignoring a plebiscite

It is easy to envisage some arguments that MPs might use in an attempt to justify ignoring a plebiscite and voting contrary to its result.

Voting in a plebiscite is only compulsory if the legislation providing for it requires compulsory voting. If voting in the plebiscite were not compulsory, its result might not reflect the views of a majority of Australians. One way to avoid this argument being raised would be to ensure that voting in the plebiscite is compulsory, as it is for elections and referenda.

Also, if members of the House of Representatives and Senate represent an electorate or state respectively, there might also be an argument that they should have regard to the vote of those they represent, rather than the majority of the population.

Suppose a majority of Australians voted in favour of legalising same-sex marriage, but a majority of people from South Australia were against it. Should a South Australian senator have regard to the views of only South Australians? In a party-political system, there are few occasions when members and senators solely consider the views of those in their electorate or state, so doing so on this occasion would seem rather selective.

Finally, given the plebiscite is to be held after the next election, it would be possible for an MP to be elected having campaigned solely on this issue, promising to vote a particular way should same-sex marriage legislation come before the parliament. That MP might argue that those who elected them gave them a mandate to vote a particular way on this issue. In those circumstances, the MP might argue that they are justified in ignoring the plebiscite’s result.

An alternative approach?

Is there a way to prevent MPs ignoring the result of a plebiscite?

In a submission to a parliamentary committee examining the issue last year, constitutional law professor Anne Twomey suggested how a plebiscite might be used to bring same-sex marriage legislation into force. Parliament could pass legislation allowing same-sex marriage, with a clause providing that the legislation would not take effect until after the Australian people had passed a plebiscite.

If the plebiscite were not passed, the legislation would lapse.

However, using the plebiscite as a “trigger” for the commencement of same-sex marriage legislation does not avoid parliament having to pass the legislation in the first place. It would simply bring the same problem to a head earlier. Those MPs opposed to same-sex marriage would be able to vote against the substantive legislation prior to a plebiscite and could prevent the issue being put to the Australian people.

A simple solution

The parliamentary committee recommended:

… that a bill to amend the definition of marriage in the Marriage Act 1961 to allow for the marriage between two people regardless of their sex is introduced into the parliament as a matter of urgency, with all parliamentarians being allowed a conscience vote.

Legally, a plebiscite is unnecessary. As with any legislative change, all that is required is for both houses of parliament to pass a bill. A plebiscite adds a layer of complexity to the political process of deciding whether to introduce same-sex marriage legislation in Australia.

Authors: The Conversation Contributor

Read more http://theconversation.com/coalition-tensions-expose-the-flaws-of-the-same-sex-marriage-plebiscite-53749

Writers Wanted

Record year of growth for Tweed based business The Electrical Co

arrow_forward

Former US presidential candidate and acclaimed Gold medalist to headline Brisbane’s 2021 Asia Pacific Cities Summit

arrow_forward

The Conversation
INTERWEBS DIGITAL AGENCY

Politics

Prime Minister Scott Morrison's interview with Ray Hadley, 2GB

RAY HADLEY: Prime Minister, good morning to you.   PRIME MINISTER: G’day, Ray.   HADLEY: Gee, you’ve had a week.   PRIME MINISTER: Well, there's been a lot of weeks like this. This time last...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Ray Hadley's interview with Scott Morrison

RAY HADLEY: I'm going to go straight to the Prime Minister, Scott Morrison is on the line right now. Prime Minister, good morning to you.    PRIME MINISTER: Good morning, Ray.   HADLEY: Just d...

Ray Hadley - avatar Ray Hadley

Defence and Veterans suicide Royal Commission

Today the Government has formally established a Royal Commission into Defence and Veteran Suicide following approval by the Governor-General.   Prime Minister Scott Morrison said the Royal Commi...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

Record year of growth for Tweed based business The Electrical Co

While many businesses struggled to stay afloat during the COVID-19 affected 2021 financial year, Tweed Heads based The Electrical Co. completed more than 50,000 smart meter installations across Aust...

a contributor - avatar a contributor

The Most Common Reasons why Employees End Up Leaving a Company

It is important for businesses to make sure they find the right people for their open positions. That is why a lot of companies are relying on professional outplacement services. A lot of companie...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

The little Aussie face sock startup is riding the personalized gift game

In a world where everybody has different desires, interests, and goals, what can be better than giving them things that meet their individual requirements. Personalized gifts have taken on the mar...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com