Daily BulletinHoliday Centre

The Conversation

  • Written by The Conversation Contributor

Victorian child protection law reforms due to come into effect next month will give parents two years from when a child is removed to demonstrate that the child should be returned to their care. Failure to do so will result in parents permanently losing custody and children being placed for adoption.

Given the history of adoption-related abuses in Australia, adoption is often viewed with suspicion. A renewed focus on adoption may thus be a concern for some people. With the Victorian law reforms likely to increase adoption rates in the state, it is timely to consider what the evidence has to tell us.

Foster care vs adoption: the evidence

A substantive review comparing long-term foster care and adoption found that differences between the two are not as stark as is often thought.

The likelihood of a placement ending, for example, remains higher in foster care than adoption. However, rates of placement termination in foster care have reduced.

Differences in outcomes are often related to the age of the child. Children who are removed into care when they are older are more likely to experience placement disruptions and to exhibit poor outcomes, whether they are fostered or adopted.

While children need permanency and stability, the evidence does not conclusively prove that adoption is inherently more able to provide this. Long-term stable foster placements can achieve similar outcomes.

When long-term foster placements fail to achieve the goal of permanency and stability, the problem is typically one of resourcing. We must therefore ask how these same issues will not repeat in the context of adoption.

Foster carers are minimally supported financially to care for children. Adoptive families are not similarly compensated for raising children. While supports are available, they are typically not as extensive nor as responsive as is the case in foster care.

Given the need for ongoing support expressed by many adoptees and adoptive parents, the relative lack of support may undermine the presumed benefits of permanency achieved via adoption.

Resourcing and vulnerability

Issues about the resourcing of foster and adoptive parents are not the only concern. Resourcing issues often constitute some of the underlying causes of child removal in the first place.

For example, there is a dearth of early intervention services aimed at assisting parents to retain care of their children. Programs such as parenting classes, anger-management classes and psychological therapies more broadly often have long wait times in the public sector.

Similarly, there is a dearth of services available for birth parents seeking to address the behaviours that led to the removal their children. The lack of such services thus impacts the likelihood of reunification.

And it is the most vulnerable families who are potentially impacted by the lack of services. Child removal rates tend to be skewed towards particular groups of people, particularly Indigenous and/or lower socioeconomic families.

Given the vulnerabilities that underpin child protection, it is important to ask why adoption is often considered more appealing than foster care. Is it because it involves the termination of parental rights, the presumption being that adoptive parents are safer in their claim to the child? If so, we must consider at whose expense such a sense of safety comes.

Available models

Given the concerns above, we need an approach to child protection that takes the best of both foster care and adoption, rather than claiming the latter is the solution. In Victoria, such an approach is already available, in the form of permanent care.

In the case of permanent care, ongoing financial support is possible and contact with birth families is encouraged and supported. While legal guardianship transfers to the permanent care parent(s), this does not automatically mean a change of name or birth certificate for the child. Given concerns about identity in the context of adoption, the latter is important.

With wide availability of permanent care, we need to question the push towards adoption. The cynic might suggest it frees the state from financial obligations, and that an increase in adoptions will also reduce the high number of children in out-of-home care.

Given alarm is frequently expressed about the rates of children on care and protection orders, shifting children out of the child protection system and into adoption may give the appearance that the core issues have been resolved. Without sufficient resourcing, however, this will not change the key problems that led to high removal rates in the first place.

Whatever the intentions behind the push for adoption, and there may be many, they must always serve the best interests of children, both now (to achieve permanency) and into the future (to have connections where possible with their birth families).

Authors: The Conversation Contributor

Read more http://theconversation.com/adoption-not-necessarily-the-best-solution-for-troubled-child-protection-system-54467


The Conversation


Closing the Gap Statement to Parliament

Mr Speaker, when we meet in this place, we are on Ngunnawal country. I give my thanks and pay my respects to our Ngunnawal elders, past, present and importantly emerging for our future. I honour...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Prime Minister Interview with Alan Jones

ALAN JONES: Prime Minister, good morning.    PRIME MINISTER: Good morning, Alan.    JONES: I was just thinking last night when we're going to talk to you today, you must feel as though you've ...

News Company - avatar News Company

Prime Minister Bridget McKenzie press conference

PRIME MINISTER: Good afternoon everybody. The good news is that the Qantas flight is on its way to Wuhan and I want to thank everybody for their cooperation, particularly the Chinese Government as...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

Choosing the Right Coworking Space For Your Business

As the capital of Victoria in Australia, Melbourne is inhabited by millions of people and is known as one of the most liveable cities in the world. The latter is due to the city’s diverse community...

Sarah Williams - avatar Sarah Williams

What Should You Expect from A Carpentry Apprenticeship?

Those wanting to pursue a career in woodwork, whether it be to make furniture, construct buildings or repair existing wooden structures, will have to first commence a carpentry apprenticeship. This ...

News Company - avatar News Company

4 Tips To Choosing A Reliable SEO Company For Your Digital Marketing Agency

Working with a digital marketing agency Perth is the best bet in ensuring that your business is promoted well in the online space. If you are an app developer Perth, you may have to work closely wit...

News Company - avatar News Company



Graduation is the stage of life when a student receives the rewards of hard work of years. It must have taken sleepless nights and tiring days to achieve the task. Now, as you have received your cov...

News Company - avatar News Company

A Travel Guide for Vacations Overseas

There are two types of tourists. Of course, that's a sweeping generalization, and we could be talking about any possible part of traveling.  In this case, we're discussing those who stick to the ma...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Family Travel Handbook from Lonely Planet

Everything you need to know to take unforgettable trips with your children   Full of practical advice, ideas and inspiration for every type of family, Lonely Planet's The Family Travel Handbook ...

Adam Bennett - avatar Adam Bennett