Daily Bulletin

The Conversation

  • Written by Michael Vagg, Clinical Senior Lecturer at Deakin University School of Medicine & Pain Specialist, Deakin University

The Division of Paediatrics and Child Health of the Royal Australasian College of Physicians (RACP) has released a strongly worded statement about the harm caused to children in immigration detention. The statement in part asserts “as a country, we are failing the most vulnerable people in our care.” The RACP itself has been publicly opposed to the detention of child refugees since the policy was introduced.

Regardless of where one sits on the political spectrum, it is impossible to deny that feelings run high on this issue. Is it helpful for doctors to weigh in publicly? Who should decide what issues doctors have a responsibility to comment publicly on?

Medical specialty groups are represented formally by quasi-academic bodies known as Colleges. Some smaller specialty groups such as the Australasian Faculty of Rehabilitation Medicine and the Faculty of Pain Medicine are organized into Faculties of larger Colleges. To be recognized as a “specialist” in your discipline you need to be offered Fellowship of a College or Faculty.

This process has a number of archaic features and is slightly different for every specialty. At the end of the day, though, the formal leaders of medical Colleges and Faculties speak for their Fellows in public debates. When it does happen, it can be taken as a near-unanimous consensus of all the Australian and New Zealand practitioners in that specialty group.

For this reason, such statements have been fairly rare and are only released on matters in which the leadership of the College sees an immediate need to add an authoritative voice to the public debate about an issue of the day. Medical leaders are generally not keen to be seen as activists.

Their main job is to regulate and accredit the standard of medical training and practice within their specialty and they are obliged to work with Governments of all stripes for the good of the community. Political stuff can be left to the Australian Medical Association to engage with.

In recent times, though, it seems medical Colleges have been speaking out more frequently in public debate. The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners was very active in the election campaign releasing 14 statements in June alone. Mental health is frequently a topic of community discussion, and the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists releases a media statement virtually every week on relevant topics including suicide among military veterans, Don Dale centre and the Nauru files.

While some of these statements are politically contentious if seen through partisan eyes, they are released because most doctors accept that advocacy on behalf of our patients is a critical part of the service we provide to society in return for the training and privileges we receive. The public trust us to act as a conscience when we become aware of threats to the health of any part of the community.

Politicians have an uneasy relationship with activist medical organisations. They love to demonise the AMA as the “doctor’s union” when it suits them, but they find it much harder to dismiss academic bodies such as the Colleges as self-interested lobby groups. Typically their points of view are based heavily on scientific evidence combined with real-world experience. Such statements can be a formidable endorsement of a policy or an insurmountable roadblock.

Doctors see ourselves as having a privileged position in society, gleaned from our years of academic training and constant exposure to dealing with the consequences of the community’s misadventures and tragedies. Our perspective is unique, and frequently uncomfortable to hear. We know and see much more than we can ever tell. No group knows so well the actual cost in money, tears and lost potential of dealing with the health consequences of preventable tragedies.

As activists, the medical profession can be irresistible. But we have to use that power wisely and sparingly, since there is only so much exposure to its own flaws society will put up with at a time. When Colleges speak out, it would pay to listen.

Authors: Michael Vagg, Clinical Senior Lecturer at Deakin University School of Medicine & Pain Specialist, Deakin University

Read more http://theconversation.com/doctors-or-activists-who-draws-the-line-64227

Writers Wanted

Radicalism mixed with openness: how Desmond Tutu used his gifts to help end Apartheid


Pfizer doses to be spaced out in NSW crisis, but state fails to get change in vaccination program


Alternative Hobbies for Gamers


The Conversation


Prime Minister Scott Morrison's interview with Ray Hadley, 2GB

RAY HADLEY: Prime Minister, good morning to you.   PRIME MINISTER: G’day, Ray.   HADLEY: Gee, you’ve had a week.   PRIME MINISTER: Well, there's been a lot of weeks like this. This time last...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Ray Hadley's interview with Scott Morrison

RAY HADLEY: I'm going to go straight to the Prime Minister, Scott Morrison is on the line right now. Prime Minister, good morning to you.    PRIME MINISTER: Good morning, Ray.   HADLEY: Just d...

Ray Hadley - avatar Ray Hadley

Defence and Veterans suicide Royal Commission

Today the Government has formally established a Royal Commission into Defence and Veteran Suicide following approval by the Governor-General.   Prime Minister Scott Morrison said the Royal Commi...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

Record year of growth for Tweed based business The Electrical Co

While many businesses struggled to stay afloat during the COVID-19 affected 2021 financial year, Tweed Heads based The Electrical Co. completed more than 50,000 smart meter installations across Aust...

a contributor - avatar a contributor

The Most Common Reasons why Employees End Up Leaving a Company

It is important for businesses to make sure they find the right people for their open positions. That is why a lot of companies are relying on professional outplacement services. A lot of companie...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

The little Aussie face sock startup is riding the personalized gift game

In a world where everybody has different desires, interests, and goals, what can be better than giving them things that meet their individual requirements. Personalized gifts have taken on the mar...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com