Daily BulletinDaily Bulletin

The Conversation

  • Written by Eleanor Milligan, Academic Lead, Ethics and Professional Practice, Griffith University
image

Medical students are practising invasive clinical procedures on themselves and fellow students at home as well as at medical school, a recent New Zealand study has confirmed.

These procedures commonly include inserting a cannula, taking blood, and giving injections. Less commonly, students are suturing, taking arterial blood samples and inserting nasogastric tubes.

To those working in medical education, these revelations are neither new nor surprising.

Yet the issue raises questions about the ethics and safety of this so-called self-practice, and the pressures that might lead medical students to undertake it.

Should we be concerned about students practising on themselves and their peers? Does it, as the study authors say, set up students to act unprofessionally when they graduate? Or does honing clinical skills this way ultimately benefit patients?

Not necessarily unethical

The inherent ethical dilemma in medical education is that unskilled students need to learn clinical skills by practising on, and potentially harming, others.

The New Zealand paper confirms that students are acutely aware of the responsibility to become proficient. Indeed, their desire to prevent avoidable patient harm appears to drive self-practice. Some people may see such motivation as ethical in its intention.

While there are other harms associated with self-practice – such as disposal of used sharps instruments, harm to oneself, or not getting expert feedback to correct poor technique – we believe the desire to improve through self- or peer-practice is not necessarily unethical or unprofessional.

How has training changed?

The landscape of medical education has changed in the past few decades.

Traditionally, students learned procedural skills under the apprenticeship model, typically in the clinical setting and often involving acutely unwell patients.In contrast, today, medical schools and hospitals make more use of simulation suites.

In this educational environment, trainees use a range of simulation equipment to learn and practise clinical procedures in a safe environment, under close supervision, and with immediate feedback. Such an environment aims to reduce the need to “practise” on, or unnecessarily harm, patients.

At first glance, good-quality simulation should also remove the need for students to practise invasive procedures on their peers or themselves.

However, the best simulation equipment cannot entirely replicate the complexities of the anatomy and physiology of the unwell patient. Therefore, expertise gained in simulation may not guarantee success in the clinical setting.

Students may feel that practising on peers or themselves is an intermediate step between learning in simulation and safely attempting that skill on a patient. The New Zealand study is a sober reminder that students identify the gap between simulation and reality and may seek to fill it with self- and peer-practice.

Limited access to patients on the wards, the unpredictability of exposure to certain clinical procedures, and time-poor clinical supervisors can further compound students’ feelings of being under-prepared.

It is noteworthy that 22% of students in the study reported they were unsupervised when performing a procedure for the first time on a patient. This aspect of medical training does raise concern, as unsupervised practice may entrench poor technique – and it prevents feedback that could correct performance errors.

Long-term harms?

The study authors claim that self-practice at medical school may translate into poor self-care and unprofessional behaviour as a doctor. They link self-practice to future self-treatment, and ultimately to potential prescribing abuse in a later career.

But this presumed link is tenuous at best – and there is no reason to predict that self-practice of a procedural skill as a student impacts future professionalism.

Importantly, there is a critical difference in context and motivation between doctors who have a health impairment, which may include medication abuse, and students seeking to gain clinical skill. The impaired doctor is not self-prescribing to improve prescribing skill.

Throughout the history of medicine, there are multiple examples of self-experimentation, some of which uncovered significant insights into the treatment of disease. One contemporary example is Australian physician Barry Marshall’s decision to infect himself with Helicobacter pylori to prove that the organism was linked with stomach ulcer disease. This ultimately led to a Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 2005.

What needs to change?

Some system changes may remove the drivers for students to practise unsupervised invasive procedures on their peers and themselves. Obvious first steps to take are:

  • providing guidance on minimising the risks of self-practice;

  • improving access to staffed simulation facilities;

  • including supervised practice on peers as part of procedural skills training; and

  • observing students when they first perform a procedure on a patient in the clinical setting in hospitals.

While there are isolated examples of self-practice that are extreme as mentioned in the study that may raise concern, self and peer-practice per se is not inherently unprofessional or unethical.

Should we be alarmed by the results of the New Zealand study? Definitely not. Can medical educators use this research to help students? Absolutely.

Authors: Eleanor Milligan, Academic Lead, Ethics and Professional Practice, Griffith University

Read more http://theconversation.com/is-it-ok-for-medical-students-to-practise-on-themselves-68061

Giant sea scorpions were the underwater titans of prehistoric Australia

arrow_forward

Victoria's coronavirus contact tracers are already under the pump. What happens next?

arrow_forward

The Conversation
INTERWEBS DIGITAL AGENCY

Politics

Prime Minister Interview with Ben Fordham, 2GB

FORDHAM: Thank you very much for talking to us. I know it's a difficult day for all of those Qantas workers. Look, they want to know in the short term, are you going to extend JobKeeper?   PRI...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Prime Minister Scott Morrison interview with Neil Mitchell

NEIL MITCHELL: Prime minister, good morning.    PRIME MINISTER: Good morning, how are you?   MICHELL: I’m okay, a bit to get to I apologise, we haven't spoken for a while and I want to get t...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Prime Minister Interview with Ben Fordham

PRIME MINISTER: I've always found that this issue on funerals has been the hardest decision that was taken and the most heartbreaking and of all the letters and, you know, there's been over 100...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

SEO In A Time of COVID-19: A Life-Saver

The coronavirus pandemic has brought about a lot of uncertainty for everyone across the world. It has had one of the most devastating impacts on the day-to-day lives of many including business o...

a Guest Writer - avatar a Guest Writer

5 Ways Risk Management Software Can Help Your Business

No business is averse to risks. Nobody can predict the future or even plan what direction a business is going to take with 100% accuracy. For this reason, to avoid issues or minimise risks, some for...

News Company - avatar News Company

5 Ways To Deal With Unemployment and Get Back Into the Workforce

Being unemployed has a number of challenges and they’re not all financial. It can affect you psychologically and sometimes it can be difficult to dig your way out of a rut when you don’t have a job ...

News Company - avatar News Company



News Company Media Core

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion