Daily BulletinDaily Bulletin

The Conversation

  • Written by Marilyn McMahon, Associate Professor in Law, Deakin University

In a rare decision, a young woman who encouraged another teenager to kill himself has been found guilty of manslaughter. A Massachusetts judge found that Michelle Carter’s text messages to her boyfriend, Conrad Roy III, contributed to Roy’s suicide by carbon monoxide poisoning.

The case marks a controversial development in the criminal law. The question of whether Carter’s conduct would constitute manslaughter in most states and territories in Australia boils down to whether long-distance bullies can be held responsible for another’s suicide.

The facts of the case

Roy had a history of depression and had previously attempted suicide. When he started expressing a desire to take his life, Carter originally discouraged him from doing so. However, she later started encouraging Roy. In a series of text messages, she repeatedly told him:

You just need to do it.

Tonight is the night. It’s now or never.

Carter even provided information about how long it would take him to die from carbon monoxide poisoning:

Just park your car and sit there and it will take, like, 20 minutes … It’s not a big deal.

If you do it right … it will 100% work. It’s not that hard to mess up.

At one point, as his car was filling with noxious fumes, Roy became sick and scared. He got out of the car and contacted Carter. She told him to:

Get back in.

It was this final comment that sealed Carter’s fate. The judge said that when Roy exited his car, he broke the “chain of self-causation” – and Carter’s exhortation to him to “get back in” established her responsibility for his death.

The case, although controversial, is not unprecedented. Two previous cases in the US have found defendants liable for manslaughter for encouraging someone else to commit suicide. One involved a game of Russian roulette. Another involved the defendant loading a gun, giving it to his wife, and encouraging her to use it to kill herself.

What was novel about the Carter case is that the accused was found guilty of homicide on the basis of words alone, and that she was miles away from Roy at the time of his death.

Watch the verdict from US juvenile court Judge Lawrence Moniz in Bristol County, Massachusetts.

Would this be a crime in Australia?

Carter’s conduct could easily be captured by several laws in Australia. For one thing, it is already a crime to incite another person to commit suicide.

In addition, laws introduced in Victoria after Brodie Panlock took her life in 2006 make it a crime to send an email or text message to another person with the intention of causing them to harm themselves.

But those crimes can only be punished with five or ten years in prison. The maximum penalty for manslaughter, on the other hand, is 20 years.

From the viewpoint of the criminal law, the most difficult task for the prosecution would be to establish causation.

Can Carter be said to have caused Roy’s death, or would his act of suicide be considered an independent act, an exercise of free will, for which he was solely responsible? The trial judge in Carter’s case found that her act of encouraging Roy to “get back in” his car started the clock on her responsibility for what happened afterwards.

Whether a judge in Australia would reach a similar conclusion is yet to be seen, but here’s what we do know.

To prove that a person’s act, such as sending an SMS or making comments during a phone call, caused a particular result (such as someone else committing suicide) the act must have “substantively contributed” to the suicide, or suicide must have been a “reasonably foreseeable” consequence. It is certainly arguable that Carter’s repeated messages substantively contributed to Roy’s death and that his death was a reasonably foreseeable consequence of her encouragement.

In South Australia, Carter’s conduct might have constituted murder, an even more severe charge than Carter faced in the US, as a person in that state who uses “undue influence” to induce another person to commit suicide may be liable for murder.

Can texting really make you liable for manslaughter or murder?

The fact that Carter was miles away when Roy got back into the car and killed himself may be expected to cause problems in making her responsible for his death. Many people argue that this factor alone means she should not have been found criminally liable.

But given these two young people primarily conducted their close relationship through text messages and phone calls, and that Carter was on the phone telling Roy to get back into his car immediately before he died, is the fact that she was not physically present when Roy killed himself really significant?

It might be that recognising culpability for messages conveyed by telephone, SMS and online is simply bringing the law into the 21st century.

If you or someone you know need someone to talk to, for any reason, call Lifeline on 13 11 14 – 24 hours a day.

Authors: Marilyn McMahon, Associate Professor in Law, Deakin University

Read more http://theconversation.com/could-long-distance-bullies-in-australia-face-up-to-20-years-in-jail-for-encouraging-suicide-79908



Easy Ways To Attain Office Cleaning Jobs In London


How to Find the Right New Pool Builders


The Conversation


$1.8 billion boost for local government

The Federal Liberal and Nationals Government will deliver a $1.8 billion boost for road and community projects through local governments across Australia.   The package of support will help lo...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Scott Morrison press conference

PRIME MINISTER: This is a tough day for Australia, a very tough day. Almost 600,000 jobs have been lost, every one of them devastating for those Australians, for their families, for their commun...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison


Local economic recovery plans will help towns and regions hit by bushfires get back on their feet as part of a new $650 million package of support from the Morrison Government.   As part of th...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

An Increasing Demand Of Corporate Function Venues In Melbourne

With an increasing culture of corporate function venues Melbourne, there is a rising competition among professionals. In order to appreciate and honour hardworking employees, corporate owners gi...

News Company - avatar News Company

How to effortlessly promote your business

You've worked hard to build your business from the ground up, and as any successful entrepreneur will tell you brand promotion is everything. Not only do high-quality promotions build a sense of...

News Company - avatar News Company

Hotdesking might not be ‘dead’ after all

According to Christian Pistauer, Workplace Strategy director of Meta5 Group in Australia, COVID will dramatically change the commercial real estate sector in Australia for many years to come. ”...

Tess Sanders Lazarus - avatar Tess Sanders Lazarus

News Company Media Core

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion