Daily BulletinHoliday Centre

The Conversation

  • Written by The Conversation Contributor

A former official of the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC), Michael Maley, has attacked the government’s planned reform of Senate voting as internally inconsistent.

Maley says the scheme proposed will create an anomaly never previously seen at Senate elections – identical preferences for candidates may produce a formal vote if the elector expresses them “above the line”, but an informal one if they are expressed “below the line” because the ballot paper would be insufficiently completed.

Maley had a 30-year career at the AEC and was deeply involved in the 1983 drafting of the current provisions governing Senate elections. He was the recognised in-house expert on the Senate electoral system. He has lodged a submission for the brief Senate inquiry into the government’s legislation, which is being done by the Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters.

The changes in the legislation provide that a voter should number their preferences for six sets of candidates above the line, although their vote will still be counted if they mark fewer than the full six – called a “savings” provision. Below the line, voters will still have to fill out the whole ballot paper, with the one change being that the number of errors allowed has been increased from three to five.

The changes are designed to reflect the voters' wishes better than the present system, and stop the preference “gaming” that has resulted in candidates being elected with tiny votes. Their effect will be to make it difficult if not impossible for micro players to win seats.

Maley, who favours the reform provided it also applies below the line, notes that the joint standing committee recommended in 2014 partial optional preferential voting for below the line, with six candidates to be voted for in a half-Senate election and 12 in a double dissolution. This would have been consistent with the proposed above the line voting.

Maley says in his submission: “The scheme proposed in the bill is an incoherent one, with no clear underlying principles apparent.

“The current system at least makes sense, in that it prima facie requires full preferential voting both above the line and below, with allowance only for mistakes.

“The committee’s proposal of optional preferential voting both above and below the line also makes eminent sense.

“The bill’s proposal, for optional preferential voting above the line but full preferential voting below the line (again with some allowance for mistakes), makes no sense, and has not been supported by any stated justification.”

He strongly urges that the committee stand by its “original well-argued proposal for the introduction of partial optional preferential voting below the line”.

Maley also says the committee should seek from the AEC data, broken down by state and territory, on how many below the line Senate votes in 2013 would have been saved from informality under the amendment proposed in the bill – to allow two more errors – compared with the number that would have been saved under the partial optional voting scheme recommended by the committee, supplemented by appropriate savings provisions.

Authors: The Conversation Contributor

Read more http://theconversation.com/former-australian-electoral-commission-official-says-senate-voting-change-is-incoherent-55489


The Conversation


Scott Morrison Press Conference - Australian Parliament House

Good afternoon. While we are facing more benign weather conditions in the short term, this morning, I received briefings from the Bureau of Meteorology, which set out that over the medium term out...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Bushfire emergency support for primary producers

Farm, fish and forestry businesses in fire-affected regions will get the help they need to rebuild with an initial $100 million in emergency bushfire funding, which will be made available following ag...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Immediate financial support for bushfire affected communities

The Morrison Government will provide an initial and immediate base payment of $1 million to 42 of the most severely bushfire impacted councils in New South Wales, Victoria, South Australia and Que...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

How to Choose the Right Data Recovery Solution for your Business

In the modern business environment, data is one of the most important commodities. A typical B2C seller, for instance, offering home delivery service cannot deliver the product to the right addres...

News Company - avatar News Company

CrowdStrike Services Cyber Front Lines Report

New CrowdStrike Report Finds an Increase in Cyber Adversaries Turning to Business Disruption as Main Attack Objective CrowdStrike Services Cyber Front Lines Report offers observations gained from t...

Media Release - avatar Media Release

Which web design software is best for beginners

There are dozens of site-builders and software devoted to the art of creating a website. Some of these, like the one offered by Adobe, are more technically oriented and in many cases require a backg...

News Company - avatar News Company


The Family Travel Handbook from Lonely Planet

Everything you need to know to take unforgettable trips with your children   Full of practical advice, ideas and inspiration for every type of family, Lonely Planet's The Family Travel Handbook ...

Adam Bennett - avatar Adam Bennett

3 Ideas for a Family-Friendly Holiday to Bali

A family holiday is always an exciting time, but it can often come with its fair share of challenges, especially when trying to keep every member of the family happy. Thankfully, the beautiful islan...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Best Things to Do in Adelaide Hills

Adelaide Hills has long been a relaxing escape for the people of Adelaide and beyond. Its proximity to the capital makes it an accessible destination that feels like you’re miles away from the hustl...

News Company - avatar News Company