Daily BulletinHoliday Centre

The Conversation

  • Written by Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Amending the Racial Discrimination Act’s Section 18C would send a “dangerous message” from political leaders that “a degree of racism in public discourse is to be considered acceptable”, according to the Executive Council of Australian Jewry (ECAJ).

In a submission to the parliamentary inquiry into freedom of speech, the council says this could damage cohesiveness, peace and order in Australian society. The removal of the words “offend” and “insult” would leave “severe gaps in the protections provided” compared with those now provided.

But the council, which describes itself as the national representative body of Australian Jewry, favours changes in the process for the Human Rights Commission’s handling of complaints to eliminate early those without merit and strongly discourage them proceeding to court.

The council says the proposal to delete “offend” and “insult” – as promoted within the Coalition – “is based on the erroneous view that those words set up a ‘subjective test’ based on ‘hurt feelings’, which establishes too low a threshold for the operation of the section and therefore impinges excessively on freedom of expression”.

It says 18C was not intended to operate like that and the courts have not interpreted it in that way.

Without exception in every decided case, “the court has made its own assessment by applying an objective test based on a community standard, regardless of the subjective perceptions of the complainant.

"This is the way the courts have consistently interpreted the words ‘reasonably likely to’, which appear in Section 18C immediately prior to the words ‘offend’ and ‘insult’,” it says.

So the case law, including the recent controversial Queensland University of Technology case, contradicts the claim that the word “offend” sets the bar too low, the council says.

But George Williams, dean of law at the University of NSW, in his submission says that even despite the courts’ narrow interpretations, the section’s wording is too broad, with too great an impact on freedom of speech.

Williams advocates the present wording of “offend, insult, humiliate or intimidate” should be replaced with a more demanding standard such as “to degrade, intimidate or incite hatred or contempt”.

Also, “references to the subjective responses of groups targeted by the speech should be replaced with an objective test having reference to the standards of a reasonable member of the community”.

Williams argues there is a wider problem in relation to freedom of speech – a growing number of laws have been put on the books that undermine it.

For example, in 2014 it became an offence to use indecent, obscene or insulting language at the Sydney Cricket Ground. In Victoria a person commits an offence if he or she sings an obscene song or ballad in public. It is an offence to use foul language on public transport in Tasmania. More serious free speech infringements are in the security laws, Williams points out.

He says that too often, the right to freedom of speech “is given great rhetorical importance, but diminished in legislation”.

Williams says parliament should enact a statute giving “general protection for freedom of speech”.

“This would act as a much-needed counterweight to federal and state statutes that infringe the right, including Section 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act.”

Authors: Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Read more http://theconversation.com/change-process-but-not-section-18c-says-jewish-council-70346


The Conversation


Scott Morrison Virus Announcement

PRIME MINISTER: Good afternoon. Keeping Australians safe - that is the priority of our Government as we deal with what has been an emerging situation with the coronavirus. Each and every day there a...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Closing the Gap Statement to Parliament

Mr Speaker, when we meet in this place, we are on Ngunnawal country. I give my thanks and pay my respects to our Ngunnawal elders, past, present and importantly emerging for our future. I honour...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Prime Minister Interview with Alan Jones

ALAN JONES: Prime Minister, good morning.    PRIME MINISTER: Good morning, Alan.    JONES: I was just thinking last night when we're going to talk to you today, you must feel as though you've ...

News Company - avatar News Company

Business News

Having a mentor is a must to take your business to the next level

Kerstyn Walsh will have the chance to meet her business mentor, LA-based wedding planner to the stars, Lisa Vorce, which will be game-changing for growing Kerstyn’s business Kerstyn Walsh, a self-emp...

Media Release - avatar Media Release

Is Hiring a Corporate Lawyer for Your Company Necessary?

Alternative online legal services like LegalZoom, Incfile, and Rocket Lawyer provides young and budding entrepreneurs access to legal help at a much affordable price without having to hire or meet a l...

Joe Curmi - avatar Joe Curmi

Top 5 Green Marketing Ideas for Your Eco-Friendly Small Business

According to studies, about 33 percent of consumers prefer buying from brands that care about their impact on the environment. This is good news for anyone running an eco-friendly business. It’s a...

Diana Smith - avatar Diana Smith


Travelling With Pets? Here Is What You Should Know

Only a pet parent can understand the dilemma one experiences while planning a vacation. Do you leave your pets at home?  Will you get a pet sitter or someone to take care of them while you are away?...

News Company - avatar News Company

How to Be a Smart Frugal Traveller

You are looking through Instagram, watching story after story of your followers overseas at a beach in Santorini, walking through the piazza in Italy, and eating a baguette in front of the Eiffel ...

News Company - avatar News Company


Graduation is the stage of life when a student receives the rewards of hard work of years. It must have taken sleepless nights and tiring days to achieve the task. Now, as you have received your cov...

News Company - avatar News Company