Daily BulletinHoliday Centre

The Conversation

  • Written by Arie Freiberg, Emeritus Professor of Law, Monash University
Political interventions have undermined the parole system's effectiveness and independence

Last month, the chair of the UK’s parole board, Nick Hardwick, resigned after three High Court judges ordered the board to reconsider its release on parole of serial sex offender John Worboys.

Two victims successfully challenged Worboys’ release on very strict conditions after he had been in jail for ten years. But the court ruled the parole board should have inquired further into Worboys’ offending to determine the credibility of his account to the board. It also held that a rule preventing the board from publicising its reasons was invalid.

Like the UK, parole systems in Australia have received sustained criticism recently.

Parole boards, like courts, were established as independent and impartial bodies, particularly in relation to high-profile, emotive and controversial cases. The Worboys case highlights just how important this principle is.

The battle between politics and the law

In recent years, there have been three inquiries into parole in Victoria, two in New South Wales, and five in Western Australia. Reforms were necessary and have, in many cases, improved the system.

In a highly risk-averse environment, there has been a struggle for supremacy between parliaments, courts and parole boards.

In response to public pressure and recent reviews, governments have diminished or removed the powers of courts and parole boards, and restricted or explicitly guided their discretion. Examples of this include mandatory or presumptive non-parole periods, standard non-parole periods, and standard sentences with presumptive non-parole periods. Community safety is now legislatively declared as the paramount consideration in parole decision-making.

The composition of parole boards has also changed. New members and new chairs have been installed, often on a full-time basis.

Boards are increasingly bypassed when dealing with high-risk offenders who may be subject to indefinite post-sentence extended supervision or detention orders. Victoria has just established a Post-Sentence Authority to manage such cases. In some jurisdictions, enhanced panels, or two-tier reviews, are required to decide these cases.

Some governments have passed laws directed at individual offenders, such as Julian Knight, or small groups of offenders, such as police killers, that have effectively prevented them from ever being released from prison.

Victims’ voices are now commonly heard through representation on parole boards. Victims are also increasingly provided with information through victims’ registers. In addition, they may be able to make submissions to boards considering an offender’s release and are notified when an offender has been granted parole and the conditions of parole.

Most jurisdictions have recently passed “no body, no parole” laws, which are designed to decrease the likelihood of release for some offenders.

What these changes have meant

All of these interventions display a progressive loss of faith in these independent bodies. They also show increasing aversion to risk and extreme sensitivity to what governments perceive to be a growing lack of public confidence in the criminal justice system.

However, the evidence does not support the public’s lack of confidence in parole boards.

In our survey of 1,200 adult Australians, 46% of respondents agreed that “prisoners should be released to serve the last part of their sentence in the community under supervision”, while 38% disagreed. And 68% agreed society has an obligation to assist a person’s re-entry into the community after a prison sentence.

Respondents indicated their confidence in parole boards in two ways.

First, 71% of respondents agreed that parole boards try to “be fair when making decisions”.

Second, most respondents reported a preference for parole boards over courts in their ability to make parole release decisions; 61% agreed parole boards are in a better position than judges to choose appropriate release dates.

Following the decision in the Worboys case, prisons expert Theodore Dalrymple described the UK parole system as “disgraceful in theory and irredeemably unworkable in practice”, and called for its abolition.

To date, Australian governments have resisted the temptation to abolish parole completely. However, they have too often succumbed to perceived community pressure to restrict parole and limit parole authorities’ independence and powers.

Parole is an imperfect system and mistakes are inevitable. Nevertheless, like sentencing, it should remain in the hands of impartial and independent bodies. Parliaments should remember that an effective parole system provides the community with a valuable mechanism for promoting its safety.

Authors: Arie Freiberg, Emeritus Professor of Law, Monash University

Read more http://theconversation.com/political-interventions-have-undermined-the-parole-systems-effectiveness-and-independence-94248


The Conversation


Scott Morrison on Credlin

PETA CREDLIN: Thank you for your time tonight, PM I know you've got a lot on your plate. I'll get to the issue of bushfires in just a moment, but I can't let it go unremarked that with Australia Day...

Peta Credlin - avatar Peta Credlin

Scott Morrison interview with Ray Hadley

RAY HADLEY: Prime Minister, good morning.    PRIME MINISTER: G’day Ray.    HADLEY: Jeez you copped a hammering while I was away.   PRIME MINISTER: Goes with the job mate.    HADLEY: Well, yo...

Ray Hadley - avatar Ray Hadley

Immediate small business support for bushfire affected communities

In response to the devastating bushfires, the Morrison Government has today announced a comprehensive suite of measures to immediately support impacted small businesses.    This initial package ...

Scott Morrison - avatar Scott Morrison

Business News

Guide to Start E-Commerce Business

If you can read this, you have access to the internet, and since you have access to the internet, you must have thought about buying something from an e-store. Today, we live in a time very contrast...

News - avatar News

Tips To Buy Office Desks From Sydney

Desks are essential components to the makeup of any office. The right type of desk makes the workflow smoothly. The majority of the people look for desks that are comfortable to work on and need lit...

News Company - avatar News Company

2019 Hottest FinTech Startups Overview

Modern technology is experiencing rapid growth, so many industries expect a so-called revolution, and the financial world is no exception. Over the past ten years, people have witnessed the emergence ...

News Company - avatar News Company


A Travel Guide for Vacations Overseas

There are two types of tourists. Of course, that's a sweeping generalization, and we could be talking about any possible part of traveling.  In this case, we're discussing those who stick to the ma...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Family Travel Handbook from Lonely Planet

Everything you need to know to take unforgettable trips with your children   Full of practical advice, ideas and inspiration for every type of family, Lonely Planet's The Family Travel Handbook ...

Adam Bennett - avatar Adam Bennett

3 Ideas for a Family-Friendly Holiday to Bali

A family holiday is always an exciting time, but it can often come with its fair share of challenges, especially when trying to keep every member of the family happy. Thankfully, the beautiful islan...

News Company - avatar News Company